For Trade - Thread...?

@creatorlars wondering what your thoughts would be on adding a thread for trading. I realize a buy/sell thread could be a different type of thing you may or may not want to consider adding to this community, but, seems like trading could be a fun and useful (and somewhat harmless) thread.

Users could post a list of modules they have available for trade and others could PM if interested?

Just a thought…


I’m into doing B/S/T here somewhere, I just have to think about the possible repercussions (like what liability does LZX have in the scenario someone gets ripped off, etc.) Probably just need to write a policy, and have a post count limit to participate or something.


If anyone has any experience on this topic, let me know!


I’d let the responsibility lie in the hands of the users. write a disclaimer and make that a sticky.

what is your standpoint on trading / selling DIY pcb’s? (pcb’s made from schematics of LZX / Castle)
example: I have made pcb’s of the summing mixer from your site. I use 3 in my system, so I have 7 spare pcb’s.


maybe have a chat with tehn over at the lines (formerly monome) forum
that is a fantastic space
and as long as I’ve been a part of those forms I’ve never encountered issues with B/S/T

post count threshold for viewing/posting
good trader thread

I’m for it

1 Like

I made a trade via the Facebook group without any problems. Would be great to see a B/S/T thread here.

Also i can post a begging message asking for a Shapechanger :slight_smile:

1 Like

Here is an example from another forum that most of us have frequented in the past and the rules used over there for the BUY/SELL/TRADE forum. Not sure that all of this would aply and may need some variation and/or adjustment for use here, but, it could be a framework to start from…

Here are the rules for the “Marketplace” section of this forum.

Please read this post before participating in any Marketplace activities.

Any use of this website for purchasing or selling items signifies your understanding and acceptance of these rules.




Any transactions that take place are solely between the buyer and the seller. and the owners/administrators of this forum are NOT participants in the transaction and can carry or offer NO liability or responsibility should there be problems with the transaction. As with eBay, Craigslist and all other online sales, PLEASE be careful and execute strong judgement.

It sucks when someone is ripped off, but unfortunately there is very little (most likely nothing) the forum management can do to help if you should have problems with a transaction.

By participating here you agree and understand that use of this forum for ‘buy, sell and trade’ transactions is carried out fully at your own risk.


  • Two subforums have been created, ‘For Sale/Trade’ and ‘Want To Buy’

  • ANY logged in user with at least ONE post can freely view and reply to topics in either of these subforums.

  • ONLY users with 100 posts or more may create threads in the ‘For Sale/Trade’ subforum. ONLY ‘For Sale’ and ‘For Trade’ threads are allowed, any other threads started in this subforum will be deleted.

  • ANY logged in user with at least ONE post may create a new thread in the ‘Want To Buy’ subforum. ONLY ‘Want To Buy’ posts are allowed, any other threads started in this subforum will be deleted. This subforum IS NOT to be used to TRADE items.


DO NOT try to use the WTB subforum to boost your postcount. List multiple items in one post instead of making multiple posts. Edit your post when your needs change. If it looks like you are abusing the WTB subforum in order to reach 100 posts you risk getting your account deleted.

If you want to SELL or TRADE something, you need 100 posts at the forum first and you must post your thread in the For sale/trade subforum. Posts mentioning items for trade in the Want to Buy subforum will be deleted without warning.

If you don’t have 100 posts, you’ll need to participate in the community a bit more so we will have a chance to get to know something about you before you can do business here. It’s not hard. Post about music, gear, your cat, your garden, your favorite band.

If we see someone who has recently reached the 100 post threshold and is starting to create For Sale threads, we will often investigate their post history. If the vast majority are pointless bumping of postcount with single word posts etc, your account will be deleted without warning. You won’t be banned, you’ll be free to register and try again, but we will simply toast your account.

  • NO SELLING ON BEHALF OF OTHERS! For Sale and For Trade posts must be items being sold by the member making the post. No posting items on behalf of your friend or buddy from another forum.

-no houses damn

  • ALL FOR SALE POSTS MUST INCLUDE A PRICE! If you don’t include a price we’ll delete your post without warning.


It is ok to state the price you will sell an item for and say that you are open to offers.
You cannot set a “nonsense” price for an item and then ask for best offers. If you do your post will be deleted without warning. Forum administration’s decision on what is, or is not, a nonsense price is final and not open to negotiation.

It IS NOT ok to just ask for offers. Or to state that you will accept offers over a certain figure. If you do this your thread will be deleted without warning.

If the item(s) are solely FT and you do not want to sell it for cash then inviting trade offers is accepted. Giving people some idea what type of things you are looking to trade for is a good idea.

If the item(s) are FS/FT and you state you are looking for offers, without naming a price that the item is for sale at, it looks very much like you are seeking cash offers and as such your post will be deleted.


  • DO NOT START THREADS FOR YOUR ITEM ON EBAY/Reverb, NOR LINKING TO YOUR FS POSTING AT ANOTHER SITE. If you have items on eBay/Reverb, AND you ALSO have 100 posts or more you may post a link to your items ONCE in the general stickied ‘Random eBay/Reverb Thread’.

New threads that link to eBay, Reverb, ModularTrades, ModularGrid, etc. will be DELETED. Posts linking to outside sales by users with less than 100 posts will be deleted. If you have posted a sale thread at a different site, post the full ad here, not a link.

  • POST IN THE RIGHT PLACE! Do not post ‘For Sale’, ‘For Trade’ or ‘Want To Buy’ threads or posts outside the relevant subforums. They will be deleted.


  • If you have over 100 posts at the forum, you MAY list items for sale in your forum signature.

  • You MAY list ‘Want To Buy’ items in your signature regardless of how many posts you have at the forum.

  • You CANNOT link to eBay auctions or Reverb sales in your signature, regardless of how many posts you have.


  • There is an official discussion thread for the Market in the ‘Stickies’ section of the For Sale/Trade subforum. Use this thread to discuss things in the Market if you need to. Do not start new threads other than For Sale, For Trade or Want to Buy.

  • New threads that are not either ‘Want To Buy’, ‘For Sale’ or ‘For Trade’ will be deleted if they are started in the Market’s subforums.

  • Please be courteous by consolidating your format-specific modules in one FS thread.

  • You can bump your ‘For Sale’ and ‘For Trade’ threads reasonably, like every few days or once a week or whatever…

You CANNOT bump your ‘Want To Buy’ posts because you can only have one post at a time in WTB. But…

ALL users can EDIT AND DELETE their own posts and threads in WTB and FS-FT. So you can delete your WTB post and make a new one.

  • The ‘Want To Buy’ subforum automatically prunes once daily and will remove any thread that has not been replied to within 14 days.

  • The ‘For Sale/Trade’ subforum automatically prunes once daily and will remove any thread that has not been replied to within 30 days.

  • If someone is perpetually causing problems by attempting to circumvent or outright disobey these rules, they risk deletion of their account.

  • These rules are not negotiable.

  • These rules are apt to change at any time.

  • Use of this website for buying, selling or trading constitutes full understanding and acceptance of these rules.

Please be nice. Play fair. Think of the community first.

1 Like

Self-regulating via tagging responsible sellers is a good system for a healthy marketplace. That could be done here, yes?
Very interested.


Ok let’s give this a try.

I have a Brown Shoes Only triple VCA that I’m up for Trading.
Looking for Cadet Ramps, VCO or some Castle modules.


I like how the lines forum handles sales better than Muffs. The main thing about lines is that the sales topic doesn’t come up by default: you have to go looking for it. This greatly changes the emphasis and I think the attitude of people who use it.


Another vote for the lines model (separate category, hidden from main feed, one thread per seller, minimum trust level to post.)


@jnoble @Dewb
The lines model sounds nice. Although I am not that familiar with it. I am certainly not trying to suggest the Muffs model is the way to go, just the only comparable reference I could think of at the time. I like the idea of it being “hidden” from the main feed. That way a user would need to seek it out. Thanks for mentioning this option.